The decision to replace Kenya’s existing KIEMS kits has exposed a difficult question for the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC): how should the country balance the need for modern election technology with concerns surrounding the track record of previous suppliers?
The controversy has intensified following criminal charges filed by the United States Department of Justice against Smartmatic’s parent company, SGO Corporation Limited, and three of its executives over an alleged bribery and money laundering scheme involving election contracts in the Philippines.
The case has added an international dimension to Kenya’s debate over the procurement of technology for the 2027 General Election, particularly as the IEBC moves to replace the existing Kenya Integrated Elections Management System (KIEMS) equipment.
In October 2025, a federal grand jury in Florida returned a superseding indictment accusing SGO Corporation Limited, which is commonly known as Smartmatic or the Smartmatic Group, of participating in a scheme involving more than US$1 million in alleged bribes to a former chairman of the Philippine Commission on Elections (COMELEC).
According to US prosecutors, the alleged payments were intended to secure and retain election-related contracts in the Philippines. Prosecutors further alleged that inflated voting machine invoices, fraudulent contracts, sham loan agreements and transactions through bank accounts in different jurisdictions were used to conceal the payments.
The charges followed an earlier indictment in August 2024 against three Smartmatic executives and the former Philippine election official.
Smartmatic has rejected the allegations, describing the charges as wrong on the facts and the law. The company has said it will contest the case.
Although the allegations have not been established in court, the prosecution raises legitimate questions about the due diligence that public institutions should undertake when procuring sensitive electoral technology.
Kenya’s decision to replace KIEMS kits
In June 2026, the Ministry of Information, Communication and the Digital Economy released an independent technical assessment of the existing KIEMS equipment.
The assessment recommended decommissioning and replacing the ageing kits with newer technology capable of reducing obsolescence, lowering long-term costs and supporting emerging technologies, including artificial intelligence.
The recommendations provided a technical basis for the IEBC’s move to procure replacement election equipment.
The procurement has, however, attracted political attention, with former Deputy President Rigathi Gachagua questioning the decision to move away from Smartmatic, which supplied the technology used in the 2022 General Election.
Gachagua argued that retaining the existing provider would avoid the risks associated with transferring voter data to a new supplier and introducing an unfamiliar system less than a year before the polls.
“Why do we have to remove, to get data from a company that is already in the country and give it a new entrant? What is the gain?” he asked.
He also raised concerns about the possibility of interference with the voter register during the transition. Those allegations require independent evidence and should not be treated as established findings.
The debate illustrates the competing considerations facing the electoral commission: continuity and operational readiness on one hand, and technological renewal, procurement integrity and long-term value on the other.
Lessons from the 2022 elections
Kenya’s experience with election technology in 2022 provides another important reference point.
Three Smartmatic representatives were arrested at Jomo Kenyatta International Airport over election-related materials they were reportedly carrying without the required declarations and official coordination. The incident attracted considerable public attention and raised questions about the handling and deployment of election materials.
The European Union Election Observation Mission’s final report also identified serious weaknesses in the implementation and management of election technology.
Among the concerns was weak access control in the biometric voter registration system, which allowed multiple users to access the system through the same account and exercise permissions beyond those they should have had.
The report noted that these weaknesses undermined accountability for unauthorised operations and exposed deficiencies in the IEBC’s supervision of the technology implementation.
Importantly, the observation mission’s findings concerned the implementation and oversight of the electoral technology system. They should not automatically be interpreted as proof that Smartmatic deliberately manipulated election results.
Nevertheless, the findings underline why the security, accountability and independent verification of election technology must be central to the 2027 procurement.
Procurement scrutiny must go beyond political arguments
The controversy is also unfolding against the backdrop of procurement disputes surrounding the replacement election technology.
In September 2026, the Public Procurement Administrative Review Board directed the IEBC to review its tender documents after identifying deficiencies in the evaluation criteria and technical requirements.
The decision highlights the importance of transparent procurement procedures, clear technical specifications and objective evaluation standards when selecting a supplier for a system that will play a critical role in the country’s democratic process.
Neither the decision to retain an existing supplier nor the introduction of a new provider should be determined by political pressure.
The IEBC must demonstrate that its choice is based on technical suitability, security, reliability, financial value and the ability to deploy and test the system within the available timeframe.
The US criminal proceedings involving Smartmatic should form part of the due diligence considerations, alongside the company’s response, its record in previous assignments and the specific requirements of Kenya’s procurement laws.
Ultimately, the responsibility lies with the IEBC to assure Kenyans that whichever technology is selected will meet the constitutional standards of simplicity, accuracy, verifiability, security, accountability and transparency.
The credibility of the 2027 General Election will depend not only on the technology procured but also on the transparency of the process, the independence of the electoral commission and the ability of Kenyans to independently verify the results.
